10 Clever Ways to Reuse Halloween Decor for Thanksgiving

Sharing is caring!

Can we talk about how Halloween ends and suddenly everyone’s posting their perfectly curated Thanksgiving tablescape like they didn’t just have plastic skeletons hanging from their chandelier? I’m over here looking at my pile of orange pumpkins and black candles thinking there’s GOT to be a way to make this work without starting from scratch.

You know what really gets me? That guilt that creeps in when you’re packing away all your Halloween decor, knowing you dropped way too much money on stuff you used for like three weeks. Then you scroll through Instagram and see all these gorgeous Thanksgiving setups and your brain immediately goes to your credit card balance. Been there, done that, bought the overpriced fall throw pillow to prove it.

My cousin Maria called me last week panicking because she’d spent way too much on Halloween decor and her mom was coming for Thanksgiving expecting that Martha Stewart vibe. “What am I supposed to do with all these spooky pumpkins?” she asked. That conversation sparked this whole thing because I realized we’re all throwing money away when we could be getting creative instead.

Here’s the truth: good fall decor is good fall decor, whether it’s got bats on it or turkeys. The colors, the textures, the cozy vibes, they’re all the same foundation. You just need to know how to shift the story your decor is telling. And trust me, after years of being broke in my twenties and having to make something out of nothing, I’ve figured out some pretty clever tricks.

My mom always used to say, “Use what you have before you buy what you want,” and I swear that woman could turn a cardboard box into something you’d want to display. She’d probably laugh at all the money we spend on seasonal decor when half of it could work year-round with a little creativity.

So here’s what I’ve learned through trial, error, and way too many late-night Pinterest sessions…

Why This Actually Matters More Than You Think

Look, I get it. On the surface, this feels like just another crafty blog post telling you to hot glue some leaves onto stuff. But here’s why I’m actually passionate about this: it’s about changing how we think about the things we bring into our homes.

Every time you transform something instead of tossing it, you’re building this muscle of creativity and resourcefulness that makes life so much richer. My grandmother could make a feast out of leftovers and turn old fabric scraps into something beautiful, and I think we’ve lost some of that ingenuity in our Amazon Prime world.

Plus, when you look at your Thanksgiving table knowing you created something unique instead of buying the same Target collection everyone else has, that feels pretty special. Your guests are going to remember the story behind that transformed centerpiece way more than they’d remember another generic fall arrangement.

And let’s be real about the money piece: the average person spends around $100-150 on seasonal decor that gets used for maybe six weeks total. When you start thinking about your decorations as investments that can be transformed and reused, that same money suddenly goes so much further.

Don’t Miss These Game-Changing Details

The biggest mistake I see people making is thinking transformation means covering everything up or completely hiding what it used to be. Sometimes the best results come from embracing the contrast, like that black table runner I mentioned that looks so much more sophisticated when you layer it instead of replacing it.

Also, lighting is EVERYTHING and most people totally overlook this. Those orange Halloween string lights? Don’t pack them away. They create the most gorgeous warm glow for Thanksgiving dinner, way better than harsh overhead lighting. I learned this by accident when I was too lazy to take down my Halloween lights and ended up loving how they looked with my Thanksgiving table.

Another thing people miss: scent. You can completely change the vibe of a space just by swapping out candles. That black lantern that held a “witches brew” candle for Halloween becomes instantly cozy when you put a “pumpkin spice” or “apple cinnamon” candle inside.

• Before you hit “buy” on your next decor order, there’s a free 10-second step you should never skip: checking Rakuten (Ebates). I simply find the store name, click the deal, and shop like normal, and Rakuten sends me real cashback! Prices keep climbing everywhere, but this is one way to get a little back on the things you were going to purchase anyway. New members even get a $30 bonus when they spend $30 — which means your first order could pay you back instantly. Don’t miss out again. Click here to sign up and save money!

*Disclosure: This post includes affiliate links. I may earn a small commission if you join Rakuten through my link — but it doesn’t cost you anything extra. In fact, you’ll actually save more!

Here’s something I wish someone had told me earlier: don’t feel like you have to transform everything at once. I usually pick three main pieces to focus on and leave the rest packed away. It’s better to do a few transformations really well than to half-heartedly change everything and have it look chaotic.

1. Give Those Pumpkins a Thanksgiving Glow-Up

Save

This one’s a no-brainer but hear me out. Those orange pumpkins you bought for Halloween? They’re already perfect fall colors. I grabbed some gold spray paint from the craft store (the good stuff, not the dollar store kind that flakes off) and went to town on my fake pumpkins. Added some copper accents with a brush and suddenly they looked like something from a fancy fall photoshoot.

For the real pumpkins that aren’t carved yet, I’ve been hot-gluing dried leaves around the stems and tucking in some of those burgundy berries you can find at any grocery store. It gives them this gorgeous harvest vibe that screams gratitude instead of “boo.”

2. Strip Your Wreaths Down and Build Them Back Up

Save

You know that wreath on your front door with the plastic bats and fake spider webs? Don’t toss it. I spent one Sunday afternoon carefully removing all the spooky stuff (saved the bats in a box for next year because I’m not wasteful like that) and replaced them with pinecones I collected on a walk and some dried corn husks.

My neighbor saw me doing this and now she’s convinced I’m some kind of crafting genius. Really, I just didn’t want to spend another $40 on a new wreath when the base was perfectly good.

3. Turn Spooky Lanterns into Cozy Candle Moments

Save

Those black metal lanterns that looked so gothic and mysterious for Halloween? They’re about to become your favorite fall accent pieces. I filled mine with acorns (free if you know where to look), some mini Indian corn, and a few of those tiny pumpkins. Swapped out the black candles for these incredible cinnamon apple ones I found at Target.

The whole vibe shifted from haunted house to cozy cabin, and the warm light hitting all those natural textures is pure bliss in the evening.

4. Layer Your Halloween Table Runner into Something Fresh

Save

Here’s where I got a little creative because I had this gorgeous black table runner with subtle orange stitching that I just couldn’t bear to pack away. So I layered it UNDER a piece of natural burlap I had leftover from another project. Then I scattered some pears, a few red apples, and those beautiful orange and red leaves that are everywhere right now.

The black still peeks through just enough to add depth, but now it looks intentional and sophisticated instead of leftover Halloween.

5. Transform Your Spooky Figurines (Yes, Really)

Save

This one sounds crazy but stick with me. Remember that ceramic black cat that’s been sitting on your mantel? A little bit of brown paint and suddenly it’s a turkey. I’m not even kidding. My friend Jessica did this with her Halloween ravens and now they look like they belong in a rustic farmhouse Thanksgiving setup.

It’s become this fun conversation starter when people come over because they can’t quite figure out why the turkey looks familiar.

6. Create Gratitude Garland from Halloween Leftovers

Save

I had this string of felt bat cutouts that I loved but obviously couldn’t keep up through Thanksgiving. So I carefully removed each bat and replaced them with paper leaves that I cut from brown grocery bags (waste not, want not, right?). Then I had everyone in the family write one thing they’re grateful for on each leaf.

Now it’s hanging across my kitchen window and every morning when I’m making coffee, I get to read all these sweet little reminders of what matters.

7. Turn Trick-or-Treat Buckets into Harvest Centerpieces

Save

Those plastic cauldrons and Halloween buckets are actually the perfect size for centerpieces. I filled mine with wheat stalks I bought from the farmer’s market, some branches I pruned from my backyard, and a few of those decorative gourds that look like they came straight from a Norman Rockwell painting.

Pro tip: if your bucket is bright orange or has cartoon characters on it, wrap it in burlap and tie it with a ribbon. Instant sophistication.

8. Mason Jar Jack-o’-Lanterns Get a Makeover

Save

Remember those adorable jar-o’-lanterns everyone was making? I couldn’t bring myself to throw them away, so I peeled off the face stickers, wrapped them in natural twine, and dropped in some battery-operated tea lights. Now they’re giving off this soft, warm glow that’s perfect for a Thanksgiving dinner.

I lined them up down the center of my dining table between some mini pumpkins and it looks like something straight out of Country Living magazine.

9. Halloween Props Become Thanksgiving Place Cards

Save

This idea came to me when I was stressing about place cards for Thanksgiving dinner and spotted my mini plastic pumpkins in the Halloween box. I painted each one with chalkboard paint and now I can write guests’ names on them with chalk. They double as little take-home gifts too.

My sister used her skeleton hands (I know, I know) as place card holders by sticking little flags with names into their grasp. Sounds morbid but it actually looks quirky and fun.

10. Give Your Outdoor Halloween Display a Thanksgiving Refresh

Save

That Halloween setup on your porch doesn’t have to completely disappear. I kept my hay bales and corn stalks (because those were expensive) and just swapped out the carved pumpkins for whole ones. Added some mums in fall colors and a cozy throw blanket draped over my porch chair.

The bones of good fall decor are the same whether it’s spooky season or gratitude season, you just shift the accessories and the whole mood changes.

Final Thoughts

Listen, I’m not saying you need to keep every single Halloween decoration through Thanksgiving (please, for the love of all that’s holy, put away the skeleton in the rocking chair). But with a little creativity and maybe a can of spray paint, you can stretch your decor budget and keep that fall feeling going strong.

When you transform something instead of just buying new, it feels more intentional, more personal, and way more fun than just following the same Pinterest boards everyone else is copying. Your wallet will thank you, Mother Earth will thank you, and you might just discover you’re more creative than you thought.

The best part is watching your family’s faces when they realize that gorgeous centerpiece used to be your spooky Halloween display. It’s like a little trick that keeps on giving, and those are the moments that make a house feel like home.

If anyone asks where you got your “new” Thanksgiving decor, just smile and say you have your sources. They don’t need to know your source was last month’s Halloween clearance section.

Questions I Always Get About This

Q: What if my Halloween stuff is really, REALLY spooky? Like, can I actually make a plastic skull work for Thanksgiving? A: I’m gonna be real with you: some things are just too far gone. That life-sized skeleton? Pack it up. But you’d be surprised what a little paint can do. I’ve seen people turn plastic skulls into really cool planters for fall mums by painting them cream or bronze. It’s edgy in a chic way, not scary. But if it makes your grandma uncomfortable, just save it for next Halloween.

Q: How do I know when I’m trying too hard to make something work? A: Trust your gut. If you’re standing there with a hot glue gun trying to turn a plastic zombie into a turkey for the third time, step away from the craft supplies. The best transformations feel natural, not forced. When my friend spent two hours trying to make vampire fangs look like… I don’t even know what, I had to stage an intervention. Some things are just meant to be Halloween-only.

Q: Is it weird to mix Halloween and Thanksgiving elements together? A: Not at all. Some of my favorite setups have a little edge to them. That black and orange color scheme is actually really sophisticated when you add in some gold and burgundy. Think gothic harvest vibes rather than trying to make everything look like a Hallmark movie. Your home should reflect your personality, not some magazine’s idea of what fall “should” look like.

Q: What’s the one thing I need to invest in if I’m going to do this every year? A: Good spray paint and a set of brushes for detail work. I’m talking about the stuff that actually sticks and doesn’t chip off after a week. It’s the difference between your DIY project looking homemade-cute versus homemade-tragic. Also, a hot glue gun that doesn’t burn your fingers off, learned that one the hard way.

• Before buying anything online, check Rakuten (formerly Ebates) — either with the browser extension or directly on Rakuten.com. Just type in your store, click the current deal, and shop as usual. Every purchase earns you cashback that can be mailed to you or sent via PayPal. In today’s economy, even a few dollars back can turn into a Starbucks latte, McDonald’s fries for the kids, or a little treat you don’t have to budget for. If you’ve never used Rakuten before, you’re missing out on free money — and right now, you’ll even get a $30 bonus when you spend your first $30. Click here to sign up and stop letting your online orders steal from you. Click here to sign up and save money!

*Disclosure: This post includes affiliate links. I may earn a small commission if you join Rakuten through my link — but it doesn’t cost you anything extra. In fact, you’ll actually save more!