I’m obsessing over vintage Halloween vibes this year. Like, I was scrolling through my grandmother’s old photo albums last weekend, and there’s this picture of her from the 1950s at a Halloween party looking absolutely stunning in this handmade witch costume. It got me thinking—why don’t we make Halloween crafts the way they used to? You know, with actual heart and soul instead of just grabbing plastic decorations from the store?
So I rounded up my brother’s daughter last Tuesday night (bribed her with hot chocolate, not gonna lie), and we dove headfirst into creating some seriously magical vintage-inspired Halloween crafts. These aren’t your typical Pinterest projects—they’re the kind of crafts that make your house feel like it stepped out of a classic horror movie in the best possible way.
1. Felt Ghost & Bat Garland
Remember those paper chain decorations we used to make as kids? This is like the grown-up, way cooler version. I found this gorgeous cream-colored felt at a little fabric shop downtown, and honestly, cutting out these retro ghost shapes was so therapeutic I almost didn’t want to stop. The bats we cut from charcoal gray felt, and when you string them all together on some rustic twine, it looks like something straight out of a 1940s Halloween party.
My brother’s daughter got obsessed with making the ghost faces—she gave each one a slightly different personality. Some look surprised, others mischievous, and one looks like it’s mid-yawn, which honestly made us both crack up. We hung ours across the mantle, but it would look incredible draped along a staircase or even across a bedroom doorway.
2. Autumn Pumpkin Fairies
Okay, so this idea came to me when I was wandering through the farmer’s market and saw these tiny pumpkins that were just begging to be turned into something magical. Picture this: mini pumpkins dressed up like little woodland fairies with fabric scraps for skirts and felt wings. It’s giving major 1950s Halloween party energy—like something you’d see at a neighborhood gathering where everyone actually knew each other’s names.
We used some vintage lace I inherited from my great-aunt (she would’ve loved this, honestly) and added little pearl buttons we found at a thrift store. Each fairy has its own personality, and they’re sitting on our kitchen windowsill right now, catching the morning light like tiny guardians of autumn magic.
3. Clay Eyeballs
Can I just say how weirdly satisfying it is to roll clay into perfect little eyeball shapes? My brother’s daughter thought I’d lost my mind when I suggested this craft, but thirty minutes in, she was completely absorbed in painting the most detailed iris patterns. We used air-dry clay because, let’s be honest, ain’t nobody got time for kiln firing.
The trick is using those classic Halloween colors—deep oranges, forest greens, and that perfect blood red. We displayed ours in mason jars around the living room, and every time someone walks by, they do this little double-take that makes me giggle. It’s giving vintage apothecary meets quirky art installation.
4. Groovy Ghosts with Upcycled Sheets
I had this “aha!” moment while sorting through old linens—what if we turned these vintage sheets into the cutest ghost family ever? Not scary ghosts, mind you, but the kind that would attend a 1960s Halloween sock hop. We cut flowing ghost shapes and added little ribbon bows at their necks, plus felt faces that look more charming than spooky.
- Before you hit “buy” on your next decor order, there’s a free 10-second step you should never skip: checking Rakuten (Ebates). I simply find the store name, click the deal, and shop like normal, and Rakuten sends me real cashback! Prices keep climbing everywhere, but this is one way to get a little back on the things you were going to purchase anyway. New members even get a $30 bonus when they spend $30 — which means your first order could pay you back instantly. Don’t miss out again. Click here to sign up and save money!
*Disclosure: This post includes affiliate links. I may earn a small commission if you join Rakuten through my link — but it doesn’t cost you anything extra. In fact, you’ll actually save more!
The best part? Each sheet had its own subtle pattern or texture, so every ghost has this unique vintage personality. One’s made from a floral pillowcase, another from striped cotton, and they’re all just floating around our house like the friendliest haunting ever.
5. Halloween Tassels
Sometimes the simplest ideas hit the hardest, you know? I was at my friend’s house last week, and she had these gorgeous tassels hanging from her bookshelf that were giving me major interior design envy. So naturally, I came home and made Halloween versions using black, orange, and cream yarn.
They’re hanging from our door handles, the mantle, even a few cabinet knobs, and honestly? They transform the whole vibe of a room. It’s like adding a whisper of vintage Halloween everywhere without going full-on haunted house. Plus, making tassels is stupidly relaxing—perfect for those evenings when you need your hands busy but your mind calm.
6. Witch Hat & Matching Pet Hat
This might be my favorite thing we made, hands down. Picture this: matching witch hats for me, my brother’s daughter, AND our golden retriever. Yes, our dog now owns a witch hat, and yes, she wore it for exactly thirty seconds before giving me the most judgmental look I’ve ever received from a four-legged creature.
We hand-sewed them from black felt and added vintage brooches I found at an estate sale. The velvet ribbon trim makes them feel legitimately witchy, not costume-y. My brother’s daughter’s been wearing hers around the house like it’s part of her regular wardrobe, which honestly makes my heart so full.
7. Framed Halloween Ephemera Art
You know how some people can walk into a thrift store and immediately find treasure? That’s exactly what happened when I stumbled upon this box of vintage Halloween postcards and advertisements. They had this incredible aged quality—the kind you can’t fake with filters.
We arranged them collage-style in mismatched frames (also thrift store finds) and created this whole vintage Halloween gallery wall. Each piece tells a story from decades past, and there’s something so beautiful about preserving those moments and making them part of our own Halloween traditions.
8. Retro Paper Candle Decor
This craft was born out of pure desperation when I realized I had zero Halloween decorations and a house full of empty toilet paper rolls. But sometimes the best ideas come from making do with what you’ve got, right? We painted them in rich blacks, warm oranges, and antique golds, then topped each one with tissue paper flames.
They look like they belong at a 1950s Halloween gathering—sophisticated but playful. We clustered them on the dining table with some real autumn leaves, and honestly, guests keep asking where I bought them. The secret weapon? A little metallic gold paint dabbed around the edges for that vintage candlestick effect.
9. DIY Potion Bottles
I’ve been saving glass bottles for months without really knowing why (classic me), and it turns out they were waiting for this exact moment. We turned them into the most enchanting apothecary collection with homemade aged labels—”Witch’s Brew,” “Spider Venom,” “Moonlight Elixir.”
The aging technique is everything: tea-stained paper, slightly torn edges, and handwritten script that looks like it came from an old spell book. We filled them with colored water, glitter, even some dried herbs from the garden. They’re sitting on floating shelves in our kitchen right now, catching light and casting the most magical shadows.
10. Pedestal Skulls
Walking through the thrift store last Saturday, I spotted these gorgeous vintage candle holders and lamp bases that were practically screaming “turn me into Halloween decor!” We spray-painted them in matte black and metallic bronze, then topped each with plastic skulls for this Victorian parlor meets modern gothic vibe.
They’re giving serious antique shop energy—the kind where you’re not sure if something’s genuinely haunted or just really, really old. My brother’s daughter was initially skeptical (she called them “extra”), but now she’s constantly rearranging them like they’re precious art pieces.
11. Vintage Black Cat Decor
There’s something so perfectly Halloween about those classic black cat silhouettes from the 1920s and ’30s, you know? All arched backs and mysterious eyes. We cut them from thick black felt and positioned them around the house like they’re mid-prowl—one on the mantle, another “walking” along a bookshelf, and my personal favorite perched on top of our piano.
The key is getting that vintage cat posture just right—not cartoon-y, but elegant and slightly mysterious. They cast the most beautiful shadows when the evening light hits them, and honestly, they’re staying up way past Halloween because they just make everything feel more sophisticated.
12. Papier-Mâché Pumpkins
Last but definitely not least—these papier-mâché pumpkins that are giving me serious vintage Halloween postcard vibes. We sculpted them with exaggerated features: wide, surprised eyes, zigzag grins, and that classic orange-and-black color scheme that screams retro Halloween.
The papier-mâché process took us back to elementary school art class, except this time we actually knew what we were doing (mostly). Each pumpkin has its own personality—some look mischievous, others genuinely startled, and one looks like it’s telling the world’s best joke. They’re sitting on our front porch right now, greeting trick-or-treaters with the kind of old-school Halloween charm that makes people stop and smile.
- Before buying anything online, check Rakuten (formerly Ebates) — either with the browser extension or directly on Rakuten.com. Just type in your store, click the current deal, and shop as usual. Every purchase earns you cashback that can be mailed to you or sent via PayPal. In today’s economy, even a few dollars back can turn into a Starbucks latte, McDonald’s fries for the kids, or a little treat you don’t have to budget for. If you’ve never used Rakuten before, you’re missing out on free money — and right now, you’ll even get a $30 bonus when you spend your first $30. Click here to sign up and stop letting your online orders steal from you. Click here to sign up and save money!
*Disclosure: This post includes affiliate links. I may earn a small commission if you join Rakuten through my link — but it doesn’t cost you anything extra. In fact, you’ll actually save more!
